- Multinationals -

poor propaganda

In Reply to: No 'stand posted by E. Wexler on October 13, 1998 at 02:08:38:

:

Let's say a close relative of yours came down with a rare disease and the cure could only be found by experimenting with a hundred rodents. Would you value a hundred rodents more than this close relative of yours? Also, are you a vegetarian? If you answered "no" to either of my questions than you are a hypocrit and need to rethink your values.

:

This is a most puzzling message. Is this pro- or anti-animal rights? Perhaps you meant that a "no" answer to one and only one of the questions makes someone a hypocrite. Still, a person could value a hundred rodents more than a close relative, not be vegetarian, and not be a hypocrite. Or could value a hundred rodents less than a close relative, be a vegetarian, and not be a hypocrite. What's more, the technique of accusing people of hypocrisy makes for poor propaganda, as it closes minds and raises bristles instantly.

Follow Ups:

None.