- Anything Else -

2 Issues

Posted by: Kevin Dempsey ( Canada ) on October 04, 1999 at 10:49:48:

In Reply to: Consider it community service. posted by Cynic on October 03, 1999 at 19:57:10:

Cynic: "...you'll find "murderers, rapists, and thieves" comes up more often than "blacks, jews, and muslims." There is a pretty clear moral core among people that transcends culture and society."

It would be interesting to see you take this statement and figure out how it applies to the ratio of convicted criminals in US prisons...

Cynic: "All murderers and rapists are just animals in their own right, anyway."

Firstly, I assume you are implying some sort of negative connotation to being an animal. Why exactly is this?
Secondly, who are you to make such a judgement (assuming here your choice of comparisons is a fair use of the term animal)? Have you ever had a conversation with a murderer or a rapist? Are you aware of how any of these PEOPLE came to do what they did? I am not suggesting you weep for them and make excuses for their behaviour, but they are PEOPLE and they DO come from circumstances. It is a little simplistic to dismiss them as animals worthy only of execution (perhaps preceded by torture.)


Follow Ups:

The Debating Room Post a Followup